Mugshots Bar & Grill 111 S Main St, Pleasantville, OH 43148
FOOD
Starters
- Capo Jalapeno Popper Cheese Bread
So good it should be illegal...it probably is..SHHH
$8.75 - The Mafioso Four
A Foursome of our famous homemade meatballs topped with homemade marinara and Italian cheeses. Huge!
$5.37 - "Get Outta Here" Green Beans
Medley of fresh green beans hand battered and fried. Served with Mafia Sauce
$7.75 - "Baby Shank's" Shrooms
Fresh mushrooms breaded in our house recipe, served with Mafia Sauce!
$8.75 - Lucky L's Fried Pickles
Hand battered spicy pickles, just like Lucky Luciano liked them. Serverd with Mafia sauce or ranch
$8.75 - Gangster Tots
Not your mama's tots! Golden brown tater tots topped with our Mafia Sauce and green onion Add Buffalo Chicken with hot sauce and ranch ($4) Add Smoked Pulled Pork with BBQ sauce
$8.75 - Big Paulie's Wings
Traditional wings fried to perfection, homemade breading and sauces. Bourbon BBQ, Sicilian, Honey Hot Mild, & Fuhgetaboutit
$8.00 - Garlic Bread with Cheese$7.75
Salads and Soups
- Mugshot's Cobb Salad
Crisp lettuce blend, local eggs, tomatoes, green onions, avocado, grilled chicken and blue cheese crumbles
$12.75 - Italian Wedding Soup
To die for, Literally! House made! Fresh veggies, meatballs, fresh parm and orzo pasta. Cup/Bowl
$4.00 - Sleeping Alone Tonight Chili
Inquire with your server! Made fresh daily. Cup/Bowl
$4.00 - Italian Chef Salad
This salad rocks pepperoni, olive, banana peppers, red onion, and cheddar jack cheese served over tossed salad. Pair this with any of our scratch made dressings.
$12.75
Main Course
- Mobster Meatloaf
Succulent "Tower" of meatloaf. Built on a base of Texas Toast, garlic mashed potatoes, onion rings and smothered with BBQ gravy.
$15.75 - Chicken Diablo
165 Year Old Recipe! Fresh Penne pasta and grilled chicken tossed in a spicy homemade Alfredo/Marinara blended sauce. Crazy good! favorite of Bugsy Siegel!
$16.75 - Tommy Gun's Mac & Cheese
Huge portion of homemade Mac & Cheese. Gruyere, American, & Italian blended Cheeses. Life changing
$12.75 - Frankie's Spaghetti
Homemade 12 hour marinara sauce! Fresh parmesan, served with garlic toast. Absolutely addicting. Our Famous Homemade meatball
$12.75 - Fettuccini Alfredo
Fettuccini noodle tossed in house-made Alfredo and sprinkled with fresh parmesan & garlic toast. Top with some of our Fuhgeddaboudit Sauce!
$12.75 - The Goodfella Trio
Fresh penne pasta served with sausage, bacon, mushroom, and onion sautéed in a carbonara sauce.
$16.75 - Baby Face Chicken Finger Platter
A generous portion of hand breaded tenders served with fresh cut fries.
$12.75
Personal Pizza
Specialty Pies
- Public Enemy #1 Meatball Madness
Featuring our homemade fresh meatballs, house sauce, fresh cheese blend, fresh basil and your choice of jalapenos or banana peppers
$21.75 - Bugsy's Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Fresh grilled chicken, pickled red onions, fresh basil and our house blend of cheeses all above BBQ sauce. Substitute for Pulled Pork $2
$21.75 - Benny's BBQ Chicken Pizza
Fresh grilled chicken, pickled red onions, fresh basil and our house blend of cheeses all above BBQ sauce. Substitute for Pulled Pork $2
$21.75 - La Cosa Nostra
Our Version of the Works! Our House cheese blend. Fresh Green pepper, Onion, Pepperoni & Banana Pepper.
$21.75
Youngin's
- The "OG" Grilled Cheese
Tired of "at home" grilled Cheese? This is for you. White/Yellow American cheese grilled on Texas Toast. Come with Gangster tots. May substitute Green Beans or onion rings.
$8.00 - Personal Pizza
Our famous cheese pizza , just smaller. Comes with your choice of 2 toppings and Gangster tots, onion rings or green beans.
$7.00 - Lil pasta
Just like our famous Entre only smaller. 12 hour marinara. Served with Garlic Toast. May also substitute marinara for our homemade alfredo sauce. Add a meatball $2 Add Chicken $2
$6.00 - Kids "Baby Face" Chicken Tenders
Hand battered chicken tenders served with mashed potatoes and Gangster Tots, onion rings or green beans.
$7.00
Desserts
- New York New York Cheese Cake
Straight from the city where it all started! Scratch made Cheesecake, a side of homemade Bourbon Cherry Sauce Whipped Cream
$7.75 - "Pretty Boy" Coconut Cake
Award winning Cake! Literally the best thing you have ever eaten! Served with a side of homemade Whipped Frosting & Chocolate Ganache
$7.75 - Sammy "The Bull" Carmel Brownie Sunday
House made Salted Caramel Brownie served with Vanilla ice cream and a side of homemade Caramel, Chocolate Ganache and Whipped Cream
$7.75 - Desert Flight (Cheesecake, Coconut Cake, Brownie)
Try all three, a few bites now and a few tomorrow morning!
$19.00OUT OF STOCK - Carrot Cake$7.75
MOO-DER INC. BURGERS
- The Mugshot
Delicious Beef smash patty infused with pork, creating an explosion of flavor. Grilled at 500 degrees to lock in those juices! Served with American cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, and pickle.
$12.75 - The JalaPacino
Delicious Beef smash patty infused with pork, creating an explosion of flavor. Grilled at 500 degrees to lock in those juices! Topped with jalapeños, pepper-jack cheese, lemon ghost pepper sauce, lettuce, and onion.
$13.75 - The Patsy
Delicious Beef smash patty infused with pork, creating an explosion of flavor. Grilled at 500 degrees to lock in those juices! Topped with an over easy egg, bacon, and lettuce drizzled in mafia sauce. You’ve been cheated your entire life without this burger. The Patsy will take place of all your guilty pleasures.
$13.75 - The Hitman
Delicious Beef smash patty infused with pork, creating an explosion of flavor. Grilled at 500 degrees to lock in those juices! Topped with pulled pork, pickle, an onion ring, and drizzled with barbecue sauce.
$14.75
Subs
- The Boss
Our Famous mouth watering meatballs piled on a toasted bun. Homemade marinara, fresh parmesan. Oven Baked perfection
$12.75 - The Italiano
House roasted pork, smoked ham, pepperoni, Mozzarella cheese, Genoa Salami, lettuce, onion, tomato, banana peppers and Oven Baked
$13.75 - Backyard BBQ Sub
Slow roasted pulled pork with grilled chicken smothered in boutbon BBQ sauce topped with cheddar jack cheese, lettuce, and onion served on a sub bun.
$13.75 - The Peeker
A classic, made with smoked turkey breast, smoked ham, Swiss cheese, applewood bacon, lettuce, tomato, and mayonnaise all atop of a sub bun.
$13.75
Mugshots Build Your Own Pizza
Gangster Clothing
Gangster Merchandise
OSU Buttons
Lucky L's Fried Pickles
Hand battered spicy pickles, just like Lucky Luciano liked them. Serverd with Mafia sauce or ranch